On this page
- Three terms the comparison turns on
- The spec sheets side by side
- Runtime at the same load
- Worked example: one gaming PC on each unit
- Outlets, joules, transfer and recharge
- Replacement battery: RB1290X2 vs APCRBC163
- What the price gap actually is
- Decision table
- What this comparison does not cover
- Frequently asked questions
The CP1500PFCLCD is the better buy for most desks. The BR1500MS2 is the better buy if you want the most minutes on battery. Both make a sine wave on battery, so neither is a risk for a modern PC, and the choice comes down to runtime against price, watts, outlets and recharge time.
The runtime gap is real, but it is smaller than the spec lines make it look. The APC is listed at 14.5 minutes and the CyberPower at 10, but those two numbers are timed at different loads. At the same load, the APC runs about 17% longer at 450 W, not 45%.
Three terms the comparison turns on
Sine wave on battery. Wall power is a smooth curve. When the power fails, a UPS makes its own power from the battery, and cheaper units make only a stepped copy of that curve. Both of these units make a smooth sine wave instead. CyberPower's sheet says "Sine Wave" for the on-battery waveform, and APC's says "Sine wave" for the wave type. Our guide to pure sine vs simulated sine shows both shapes.
Active PFC. This is a circuit at the front of most modern desktop power supplies. It expects a smooth wave coming in, and on a stepped wave some supplies shut off. Any 80 PLUS badge means active PFC. Since both units here are sine wave, active PFC does not split them. Our page on active PFC power supplies has the detail.
Half load. Makers time runtime at "half load" and "full load". Full load is the unit's watt rating, and half load is half of that. So half load is 500 W on the 1000 W CyberPower and 450 W on the 900 W APC. The two "half load" figures describe two different loads, and that one fact is behind most of the confusion about these two units.
The spec sheets side by side
These figures come from each maker's datasheet unless the table says otherwise. The CyberPower sheet is for the CP1500PFCLCDTAA, the version sold to government buyers. Its ratings match CyberPower's own page for the retail CP1500PFCLCD: 1000 W, sine wave, 10 and 2.5 minutes, 1445 J and 4 ms. APC's sheet does not print runtime minutes, so those come from a reseller listing of APC's specs.
| Spec | CP1500PFCLCD | BR1500MS2 |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 1500 VA / 1000 W | 1500 VA / 900 W |
| Topology | Line-interactive | Line-interactive |
| Waveform on battery | Sine wave | Sine wave |
| Published runtime, half / full load | 10 min at 500 W / 2.5 min at 1000 W | 14.5 min at 450 W / 4.1 min at 900 W (Levata) |
| Typical transfer time | 4 ms | 8 ms typical, 10 ms max |
| Typical recharge time | 8 h | 16 h |
| Outlets (battery + surge only) | 6 + 6 | 6 + 4 |
| Surge rating | 1445 J | 1080 J |
| USB charge ports | Type-A + Type-C, 3.1 A shared | Type-A + Type-C |
| Data line protection | Coax and network (RJ45) | Coax |
| Network card option | Yes (RMCARD205) | None listed |
| Replacement battery | RB1290X2 (2 x 12 V / 9 Ah) | APCRBC163 (APCGuard listing) |
| Weight | 24.9 lb | 27.6 lb |
| Warranty / equipment policy | 3 years / lifetime $500,000 | 3 years (APCGuard) / lifetime $500,000 |
The figures match our two single-brand comparisons. The BR1500MS2 vs BX1500M page uses the same 900 W, 14.5 minutes, 16 hours and 1080 J. The CP1500PFCLCD vs CP1500AVRLCD page uses the same 1000 W, 10 and 2.5 minutes, 8 hours and 1445 J.
Transfer time is the gap between wall power failing and the battery taking over. A desktop power supply rides through both 4 ms and 8 ms on its own stored charge, so the CyberPower's edge here is small. See UPS transfer time for why both are normal for this class.
Runtime at the same load
Neither maker publishes a runtime chart that could be read here. What each one gives is two points, one at half load and one at full load. Two points are enough to draw a curve between them and read off other loads, which is what the table below does.
On CyberPower's sheet, doubling the load from 500 W to 1000 W cuts runtime to a quarter, from 10 to 2.5 minutes. On the APC figures, doubling from 450 W to 900 W cuts it from 14.5 to 4.1 minutes, which is a little gentler. Following each unit's own slope gives this:
| Load | CP1500PFCLCD | BR1500MS2 | APC lead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 450 W | about 12.3 min (scaled) | 14.5 min (published) | about 17% |
| 500 W | 10 min (published) | about 12.0 min (scaled) | about 20% |
| 900 W | about 3.1 min (scaled) | 4.1 min (published) | about 33% |
So the raw lines overstate the gap: read straight off the sheets, 14.5 against 10 looks like a 45% lead. At one shared load it is about 2 minutes at 450 to 500 W, and about 1 minute at 900 W. The APC does run longer at every load in the shared range, but it does not run half again as long.
Our analysis: what the extra minutes are worth
Two more minutes at a typical desk load is time to save one more file, not time to ride out a long outage. If you need to ride out outages, neither unit is the answer, and our runtime guide covers what is. If you only need time to shut down cleanly, 12 minutes and 14.5 minutes do the same job.
The battery sizes fit this picture. CyberPower lists two 12 V / 9 Ah blocks, about 216 Wh on the label. APC's sheet does not print a battery size, but it does list a 16 W charger and a 16 hour recharge, against 8 hours on the CyberPower. A longer refill with a charger that size points to a larger battery in the APC.
Worked example: one gaming PC on each unit
Take a gaming PC with an 850 W, 80 PLUS Gold power supply. Suppose it draws about 410 W at the wall while gaming, and a 40 W monitor brings the battery outlets to 450 W. Here is how the two units compare for that desk.
- Check the waveform. The 80 PLUS badge means active PFC, and both units make a sine wave on battery, so both pass.
- Check capacity. Our gaming PC sizing guide plans gaming loads at 70% of the watt rating, because GPU spikes do not show on a watt meter. That is 700 W on the CyberPower and 630 W on the APC. 450 W fits both.
- Read the runtime. 450 W is the APC's own half load, so it gives about 14.5 minutes with fresh batteries. The CyberPower, scaled from its two points, gives about 12.3, so the APC buys about 2 minutes.
- Weigh the rest. Those 2 minutes cost about $60. The CyberPower also refills in a typical 8 hours, against 16 for the APC. That matters if the power drops a second time the same day.
For this desk, either unit gets the PC shut down safely, and the CyberPower does it for less money and recovers faster. Pick the APC only if the extra 2 minutes matter more to you than the $60.
Now make the PC heavier. Suppose a bigger graphics card brings the planning load to 660 W. That is over the APC's 630 W margin and under the CyberPower's 700 W, so now the APC is the wrong unit, whatever its runtime.
Outlets, joules, transfer and recharge
Outlets. Both have six battery outlets, which is what counts in an outage. The CyberPower adds six surge-only outlets to the APC's four. Surge-only outlets go dark when the power fails, so they suit a printer or a lamp that can wait out an outage.
Joules. The surge rating is 1445 J on the CyberPower and 1080 J on the APC. A higher figure means the surge parts can absorb more energy before they wear out.
Transfer. 4 ms typical on the CyberPower, 8 ms typical and 10 ms maximum on the APC. Both are inside what a desktop supply rides through.
Recharge. This is the gap with the most practical weight after runtime: the CyberPower lists 8 hours typical and the APC 16 hours. Where short outages come in clusters, as in storm season, the faster refill means more of the runtime is there for the next one.
Extras. Both have USB-A and USB-C charge ports. The CyberPower also protects an Ethernet line and takes an optional RMCARD205 network card. APC's sheet lists coax protection only and no card option.
Replacement battery: RB1290X2 vs APCRBC163
Both units take one user-replaceable cartridge. CyberPower lists the RB1290X2 for the CP1500PFCLCD, and the RB1280X2B for some serial number ranges. The cartridge holds two 12 V / 9 Ah sealed lead-acid blocks, a common battery size that is easy to find. APC's own sheet does not name a cartridge, but the reseller APCGuard lists the APCRBC163 for the BR1500MS2.
APC rates the BR1500MS2 battery for a design life of 3 to 5 years. Check the label on your unit for the exact part number before you order. Our guide to replacing a UPS battery covers the swap itself.
What the price gap actually is
SmartHomeCompared showed the BR1500MS2 at $299.99 and the CP1500PFCLCD at $239.95. That is a $60 gap at sale prices, and the same page gave regular prices of $339.99 and $274.95, a $65 gap. CyberPower's own page lists $274.95 and APCGuard lists $339.99, so the regular prices check out against a second source.
Prices move often, so treat the gap as about $60 to $65 and check on the day. The question stays the same: are about 2 extra minutes at a desk load worth that much, given the CyberPower's other wins?
Decision table
| What matters to you | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest price | CP1500PFCLCD | About $60 to $65 less at the prices above |
| Most minutes at the same load | BR1500MS2 | About 14.5 vs 12.3 min at 450 W; 4.1 vs 3.1 min at 900 W |
| Gaming planning load between 630 and 700 W | CP1500PFCLCD | Only the 1000 W rating leaves a 70% margin |
| Active PFC desktop | Either | Both are sine wave on battery |
| Outages that come in clusters | CP1500PFCLCD | 8 h typical recharge vs 16 h |
| Many surge-only plugs | CP1500PFCLCD | 6 surge-only outlets vs 4 |
| Ethernet surge protection or a network card | CP1500PFCLCD | Only its sheet lists RJ45 protection and the RMCARD205 slot |
| Equipment policy | Either | Lifetime $500,000 on both |
Bottom line
Buy the CP1500PFCLCD unless runtime is your top priority. It is cheaper, carries 100 W more, has more outlets and refills in half the time. Buy the BR1500MS2 if you want the extra minutes: about 2 at a typical desk load and about 1 near 900 W.
What this comparison does not cover
The equal-load runtimes are our arithmetic from two published points per unit, not a measured curve. The APC points come from a reseller listing of APC's specs, since APC's own sheet does not print them. All runtimes assume new, fully charged batteries, and real runtime falls on both units as batteries age and in heat. The scaled figures hold between about 450 W and 1000 W. Do not stretch them to a 50 W router load, where the curve bends in ways two points cannot show.
This page does not judge how clean either sine wave looks on a scope beyond what the sheets state. It does not cover motor loads such as sump pumps or furnace blowers, which have their own rules. Laser printers and space heaters do not belong on the battery outlets of either unit. Prices change weekly, so the gap here is a snapshot.
For how the two brands line up beyond this pair, see APC vs CyberPower. If your PC has no active PFC, each brand sells a cheaper stepped-wave sibling, compared in the two single-brand pages linked above.
Frequently asked questions
Is the APC BR1500MS2 better than the CyberPower CP1500PFCLCD?
Only on runtime. At the same load the BR1500MS2 runs longer: about 14.5 minutes at 450 W against about 12.3 for the CP1500PFCLCD. The CyberPower has the higher watt rating (1000 W vs 900 W), more outlets, more joules, a faster transfer and half the recharge time, and it costs about $60 less.
Why does the BR1500MS2 show 14.5 minutes and the CP1500PFCLCD only 10?
Because the two figures are timed at different loads. Half load means half of each unit's own watt rating. That is 450 W on the 900 W APC and 500 W on the 1000 W CyberPower. At the same 450 W, the CyberPower runs about 12.3 minutes by our arithmetic from its two published points.
Are both the CP1500PFCLCD and BR1500MS2 pure sine wave?
Yes, on battery. CyberPower's sheet lists the on-battery waveform as sine wave, and APC's sheet lists the wave type as sine wave. That makes both suitable for computers with active PFC power supplies, which includes almost every desktop with an 80 PLUS badge.
Which has the cheaper replacement battery, RB1290X2 or APCRBC163?
Prices for both cartridges change often, so check on the day. The RB1290X2 holds two standard 12 V / 9 Ah sealed lead-acid blocks, a common size that several makers produce. The APCRBC163 is APC's own cartridge for the BR1500MS2. Order by the part number listed for your exact unit and serial number.
Can either one run a gaming PC?
Yes, if the load fits. Both are sine wave on battery. Planning gaming loads at 70% of the watt rating gives 700 W on the CP1500PFCLCD and 630 W on the BR1500MS2. A PC that peaks between those two figures belongs on the CyberPower.
Sources and further reading
- APC by Schneider Electric: BR1500MS2 product data sheet (July 7, 2024)
- CyberPower: CP1500PFCLCDTAA PFC Sinewave UPS datasheet (2023)
- CyberPower: CP1500PFCLCD product page (specifications, replacement cartridges, $274.95 MSRP)
- Levata: APC BR1500MS2 specifications (backup time 14.5 min at half load, 4.1 min at full load)
- APCGuard: BR1500MS2 listing (replacement battery APCRBC163, $339.99, 3 year warranty)
- SmartHomeCompared: BR1500MS2 vs CP1500PFCLCD (price snapshot)